When Peter Jackson’s “The Beatles: Get Back” was released a few weeks ago, Beatlemania started spreading around my house (and the world, it seems) like it was 1964. For eight hours over several days, I sat mesmerized by a glimpse I’d never been offered into the Beatles’ personalities. By ’69, Paul was the sober adult in the room, George was ready to be a frontman, John was a strung-out goofball, Ringo was just happy to be there, and Yoko’s presence felt strange, but I don’t see any evidence that she broke up the band.
Needing more Beatles in my life after I finished the series, I took a trip through their discography and decided to rank my 100 favorite songs. Before I shared the list with anyone, my son convinced me that the better reveal would be as part of a series of polls on Twitter to determine the best Beatles song.
If you followed the polls, you know that “Let It Be” narrowly edged out “Here Comes the Sun”, with “Hey Jude” finishing third. The popularity of these three songs recorded right at the end of the group’s run makes one wonder just what they could have accomplished with another year or two together. What you didn’t entirely learn from Twitter was how I seeded the bracket. While my updates after each round often referred to upsets and disclosed some seedings, I was careful not to put seed numbers next to songs in the polls so as not to bias the results.
I’ve made a few tweaks to the rankings since the tournament ended, but the list below is directionally the same as the list that seeded the tourney. I included 128 songs in the bracket, but I’ll keep this countdown to the top 100, plus a few honorable mentions. Among songs seeded lower than 100th, only three won their first-round matchup on Twitter:
“I Am the Walrus”, from Magical Mystery Tour (103)
“Michelle”, from Rubber Soul (104)
“Happiness Is a Warm Gun”, from the white album (106)
I’m disappointed that each of these songs knocked off a twenty-something seed, but I could be convinced that I underseeded each of them. “Walrus” is a particularly trippy trip back to ’67, “Michelle” is beautiful and memorable, and “Happiness” is a wild romp I probably penalized too much for its title. Song #101 was “Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da”, which is either the most fun song they ever recorded or the stupidest. It might be both.
On with the top 100:
100. “Real Love”, released with a 1995 anthology
Beatles fans of my generation didn’t get to experience the legendary 11-album run in real time. Instead, we got this hopeful John Lennon demo finished by his bandmates 15 years after his death. It lacks the real-time magic of the 99 songs ahead, but it’s worth acknowledging that the incredible gift of the Beatles hasn’t stopped giving.
99. “I Wanna Be Your Man”, from With The Beatles
an early pop-rock workout with addicting energy
98. “Do You Want to Know a Secret”, from Please Please Me
A little precious, particularly for a John/George collab. The musicianship was yet to come, but the ear for pleasing melodies was there in ’63.
97. “Honey Pie”, from the white album
Those of you who, like me, spend far more time with the white album’s first disc than its second may read this title and think of the goofy “Wild Honey Pie”. This is disc 2’s saccharine throwback, with which I’m in love, but I’m lazy.
96. “She’s Leaving Home”, from Sgt. Pepper
They tried a little of everything on Sgt. Pepper, didn’t they? This song was such a carnival of sounds and octaves that it’s hardly a surprise the next song on the album was about a literal circus.
95. “When I Get Home”, from A Hard Day’s Night
A Hard Day’s Night is absolutely loaded with two-minute bursts of glee. The Monkees made millions aping this sound.
94. “Another Girl”, from Help!
93. “You’re Going to Lose That Girl”, from Help!
Well, at least another one will be available when you lose her.
92. “I Want to Tell You”, from Revolver
Revolver dips into Eastern music and closes with psychedelic effects, but the songs underneath the production sound like they could have fit on Rubber Soul. This is a pop song slowed down by a tab or two of acid.
91. “Anna (Go To Him)”, from Please Please Me
Hidden right behind “I Saw Her Standing There” on the debut record, this one might feel like a throwaway, but its slow groove evidenced the band’s songwriting chops beyond the hard-charging frenzy of the early singles.
90. “Please Mr. Postman”, from With the Beatles
They recorded a lot of covers in the early going. Some, like this one, gave a glimpse into the sound they’d make their own.
89. “Every Little Thing”, from Beatles for Sale
a simple tune, but that gong is a revolution
88. “Strawberry Fields Forever”, from Magical Mystery Tour
I learned by hosting the tournament that people love this song. I appreciate it, but among the barrage of greatness in ’67, I find the musical experimentation on Sgt. Pepper more fun than the lyrical spiritual awakening of Magical Mystery Tour.
87. “Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band”
More of an introduction to an experience than a song, I actually prefer the proto-hip-hop beat of the reprise later in the album, but I counted the recordings as one song for the sake of this countdown.
86. “I’m Looking Through You”, from Rubber Soul
Rubber Soul is a transitional album. The group demonstrated a willingness to add complexity to their songwriting, but tracks like “I’m Looking Through You” showcase the best pop-rock they recorded before they found drugs.
85. “Martha My Dear”, from the white album
Don’t forget me.
84. “All I’ve Got To Do”, from With The Beatles
Even when they weren’t directly covering Smokey and the Miracles, his influence was all over their early sound.
83. “Mother Nature’s Son”, from the white album
This is Paul, all alone, showing a depth of songwriting skill to match his vocal range.
82. “The Long and Winding Road”, from Let It Be
I’ve read a lot of hateful words about this song since the documentary came out and, frankly, it’s soured me on it a bit. On one hand, there’s an incredible evolution from the stripped-down pop of the ’63 albums to the orchestra-backed grandeur of the late stages. On the other hand, that grandeur puts a few layers between the band and its listeners. Have we seen this road before? I’m not sure, but I’m not always in the mood to follow it to its end.
81. “Hey Bulldog”, from Yellow Submarine
The true hidden gem in The Beatles’ catalog? Those who bought the rest of the albums but waited 40 years to hear Yellow Submarine on Spotify were rewarded with one high-octane action movie theme song among the dross.
80. “The Continuing Story of Bungalow Bill”, from the White Album
I hope we’re all a little less threatened by Yoko’s first appearance now that the documentary has quieted some of the chatter about her responsibility for the breakup. What did she kill?
79. “I Should Have Known Better”, from A Hard Day’s Night
Here’s the antidote to “The Long and Winding Road”. No violins; no pretension; just joy. “And I do/ hey hey hey/ and I dooooooo!”
78. “With a Little Help from My Friends”, from Sgt. Pepper
The only Ringo-sung tune on the countdown. “Don’t Pass Me By” may be the better song, but the cultural impact of this one packs it with nostalgia for a time my generation never experienced.
77. “I’ll Cry Instead”, from A Hard Day’s Night
Could the Dave Clark Five write a song like this? The Lovin’ Spoonful? Had The Beatles broken up after the two 1964 records, we would never have heard 76 of the 100 songs on this list, but I think they’d still be a top-25 band of all time.
76. “It’s Only Love”, from Help!
And in the middle years, John got sad.
75. “It Won’t Be Long”, from With The Beatles
It’s in your head right now, isn’t it? You’re welcome.
74. “The Ballad of John and Yoko”, non-album single
As a Yoko apologist, I think I love this song just because the old guard doesn’t.
73. “She Said She Said”, from Revolver
One of those Revolver songs that sounds like Rubber Soul recorded on a different planet.
72. “Tell Me Why”, from A Hard Day’s Night
Those doo-wop harmonies sound like Paul, but John was equally reverent of Black music and equally capable of moving hips.
71. “Because”, from Abbey Road
As a bit of a punsmith, I have a soft spot for this one.
70. “Back in the U.S.S.R”, from the white album
That airplane takeoff sound effect kicks off the album where they throw caution to the wind and tinker with every genre, including several that didn’t exist yet.
69. “Lovely Rita”, from Sgt. Pepper
the best song ever written about a meter maid?
68. “I’m Only Sleeping”, from Revolver
Drugs, man.
67. “I’ve Got a Feeling”, from Let It Be
The best John/Paul collaboration is 66 spots ahead, but this is a great example of the two geniuses sharing air space.
66. “From Me To You”, non-album single
One of the best laughs from “Get Back” came when John was late for a morning session and Paul started improvising a song with Ringo. The captions at the bottom of the screen credited the song to “Lennon/McCartney/Starkey”, sending up the duo’s insistence on sharing credit for each other’s songs even as they grew apart as songwriters. “From Me To You” was a true Lennon/McCartney collaboration from the days when the double credit came with some mystery as to a song’s true origins.
65. “Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds”, from Sgt. Pepper
This might be the first Beatles song that could absolutely not have been written by the same group in ’64.
64. “Revolution”, non-album B-side
This is the radio-friendly one, not either of the experiments on the white album. We all play it when we can.
63. “You Won’t See Me”, from Rubber Soul
Harmonies worthy of the Beach Boys
62. “The Fool on the Hill”, from Magical Mystery Tour
Does anyone else picture Willy Wonka’s factory, viewed through the gates, when they hear this song?
61. “Nowhere Man”, from Rubber Soul
Bob Dylan’s fingerprints are all over the ’65 albums.
60. “You’ve Got to Hide Your Love Away”, from Help!
The Beatles brought us so much joy, but the darker moments like this are a critical part of the human experience. Like kind of music they made, John and his mates dirged better than just about anyone.
59. “Helter Skelter”, from the white album
Oh, look out! The Fab Four’s first foray into heavy metal contributed to the birth of yet another genre.
58. “Hold Me Tight”, from With The Beatles
Sometimes you’ve got to hide your love away. Other times, it’s right there, waiting to be held tight. What a difference a year makes.
57. “Paperback Writer”, non-album single
This one kind of sounds like a ripoff of The 5th Dimension, but, as always, The Beatles did it first.
56. “Any Time At All”, from A Hard Day’s Night
I feel like I’ve written about this song five times already. The up-tempo songs on A Hard Day’s Night were practically indistinguishably great.
55. “Dig a Pony”, from Let It Be
This is at least 40 spots higher than it would have been had I not just watched its birth over eight hours of session footage.
54. “Oh! Darling”, from Abbey Road
Abbey Road shows up nine times in the countdown, but that’s a severe undercount, as two three-song suites show up later as individual entries.
53. “Hello, Goodbye”, from Magical Mystery Tour
This song and several others from Magical Mystery Tour are so familiar today as to sound hackneyed – almost cloying – but they must have been a revelation in ’67.
52. “Ticket To Ride”, from Help!
Speaking of ubiquity…
51. “Rocky Raccoon”, from the White Album
The Beatles song that most makes me think of my mom. That’s worth a few bonus points.
50. “Don’t Let Me Down”, non-album B-side
John seemed obsessed with this one during the Let It Be sessions. It would have been interesting to see how it came about that it didn’t make the album.
49. “Things We Said Today”, from A Hard Day’s Night
Toward the end, right after “I’ll Cry Instead”, A Hard Day’s Night takes on a more sober tone. It’s almost like the whole album supported some sort of running narrative.
48. “We Can Work It Out”, non-album single
The prevailing themes of the early albums seemed to be “hey girl, you’re swell; let’s snuggle” and “hey girl, don’t snuggle with that other guy; that’s not swell”. In the middle years, as the four pursued serious relationships, the love songs matured.
47. “Penny Lane”, from Magical Mystery Tour
This slice-of-life vignette may have been a precursor to “A Day In the Life”, which is still to come on this list.
46. “I Feel Fine”, non-album B-side
another masterclass in pop songcraft
45. “A Hard Day’s Night”
A great song, but I’m stunned that it blew thorough four rounds before bowing out in the quarterfinals. Lots of praise on Twitter for the opening chord which, to be fair, was a revolutionary way to kick off a 30-minute blast of perfect pop music.
44. “All You Need Is Love”, from Magical Mystery Tour
Things seemed to start looking up for John between his sorrowful contributions to Help! in ’65 and this fundamental statement from ’67, a template for his later solo work.
43. “I Will”, from the white album
Here’s Mom again. Mother-son dance at my wedding. The Beatles wrote a song for every occasion.
42. “Help!”
The album is all over the place; the song is straightforward and features some of the group’s best harmonies.
41. “All My Loving”, from With The Beatles
When my daughter was a toddler, we used to sing “close your eyes and I’ll” and wait for an adorable “kiss you”. Another perfect piece of pop.
40. “She Loves You”, non-album single
From a distance, the “yeah yeah yeah” feels a little juvenile, but up close, the melodies that precede the preschool chorus are divine.
39. “Twist and Shout”, from Please Please Me
A thrilling piece of music to listen to in 2022, I can only imagine what this sounded like in 1963. The song that best explains Beatlemania.
38. “Sexy Sadie”, from the white album
She’ll get hers yet.
37. “Day Tripper”, non-album single
that opening guitar riff…
36. “Please Please Me”
This appears to be the part of the countdown where the title tracks reside. I’m glad the band moved on from harmonica-driven songs, but they made great use of what they had available before the recording budget exploded.
35. “And Your Bird Can Sing”, from Revolver
One of the more sober pieces on Revolver, the harmonies are topped only by the intricate guitar work.
34. “The Night Before”, from Help!
Like the song right before this album’s closer, this one feels cheated by its placement right after the opening title track. They gave us one more infectious melody before the record takes a dark turn.
33. “Lady Madonna”, non-album single
You can hear Paul’s future solo work in the bouncing piano. This song screams ’70s like nothing else in The Beatles’ catalog.
32. “You Never Give Me Your Money”, from Abbey Road
We’re not done with the second half of Abbey Road, which is sometimes combined into a single medley, probably because this song’s melody is reprised during “Carry That Weight”. Upon closer inspection, this song starts and stops before the medley takes shape.
31. “Got To Get You Into My Life”, from Revolver
This was the biggest post-tournament gainer, moving up 29 spots. I was disappointed when this song took out “Tomorrow Never Knows” in the second round, but I came to appreciate the greatness I may have overlooked in waiting for Revolver to get to its bonkers closer.
30. “Here, There, and Everywhere”, from Revolver
There may not have been ten songwriters in the 20th century who could write a ballad this beautiful. This essay later supposes that three different Beatles wrote a better one.
29. “Two of Us”, from Let It Be
An acoustic ballad, put perhaps not the romantic one its title suggests, “Two of Us” is by far the softest and sweetest of the band’s 11 album openers.
28. “Blackbird”, from the white album
You know it by heart. Feel free to pause and hum a few bars before moving on to #27.
27. “And I Love Her”, from A Hard Day’s Night
My sister and her husband sang this song at my wedding. This album does sentimentality as well as it does straightforward pop-rock.
26. “Love You To”, from Revolver
25. “Within You Without You”, from Sgt. Pepper
George kickstarted the group’s fascination with Indian music, culture, and meditation, but John seems to have taken a shine as well. They tinkered with sitar-driven ragas on Revolver and knocked it into full gear on Sgt. Pepper. Each is a masterpiece.
24. “In My Life”, from Rubber Soul
As they transitioned from pop tunesmiths to psychedelic tinkerers, the group dropped one last Hallmark-movie-ready earworm. In almost anyone else’s catalog, it would be the pinnacle. I found myself rooting against it in almost every round of the tournament, favoring the sophistication of songwriting elsewhere.
23. “Across the Universe”, from Let It Be
One of the few Beatles songs I heard first as a cover, when Fiona Apple’s version closed out “Pleasantville”, selling at least one copy of Let It Be.
22 “I Want You (She’s So Heavy)”, from Abbey Road
One can’t blame The Beatles for tiring of writing lush melodies and retreating into the bleakness of a drawn-out dirge bemoaning unrequited lust. They deserved the break.
21. “Cry Baby Cry”, from the white album
20. “I’ll Follow the Sun”, from Beatles for Sale
19. “Something”, from Abbey Road
18. “Eleanor Rigby”, from Revolver
17. “Yesterday”, from Help!
16. “Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown)”, from Rubber Soul
15. “If I Fell”, from A Hard Day’s Night
14. “For No One”, from Revolver
Here we have eight gorgeous ballads from seven different albums, each somehow better than the perfect one before it.
13. “Get Back”, from Let It Be
Did anyone not get hooked on this song again when you first heard about the documentary? Watching the band workshop the lyrics together was a fascinating glimpse into their music-first-lyrics-second philosophy.
12. “Let It Be”, from Let It Be
The champion. I seeded it eighth, but found myself voting against it in several rounds. It’s such a brilliant piece of music that the whole world has been fascinated with it and bored by it. Your mileage only varies based on which point in the cycle you currently occupy.
11. “Dear Prudence”, from the white album
The white album’s only failing is that it tries to be everything to everyone. There’s no sense picking nits among the most complete catalog in popular music, but it’s fun to imagine an hourlong record culled from the best of the sprawling, self-titled album. Whether they stopped there or cut down to a four-song EP, “Dear Prudence” would be the epic centerpiece.
10. “Here Comes the Sun”, from Abbey Road
a worthy runner-up
9. “Mean Mr. Mustard”/”Polythene Pam”/”She Came In Through the Bathroom Window”, from Abbey Road
8. “Golden Slumbers”/”Carry That Weight”/”The End”, from Abbey Road
These six songs are often packaged with “You Never Give Me Your Money” and “Sun King” as “Abbey Road Medley”, and while that’s quite a body of work, my son noticed something when he helped me with this project. The medley pauses briefly between Bathroom Window and Slumbers. The most rousing moments on the album come during the transitions buried within these suites. “Polythene Pam” giving way to “She Came In Through the Bathroom Window” is unforgettable. The drum fills that begin and end “Carry That Weight” keep you begging for more 15 minutes into the medley.
7. “Come Together”, from Abbey Road
This project reinforced for me the greatness of Abbey Road. For all the majesty of the second side, it’s the effects that kick off the album and the off-the-wall lyrics about Old Flattop that best represent the pinnacle of The Beatles’ run.
6. “While My Guitar Gently Weeps”, from the white album
George was famously responsible for song #19 and #10, but this is peak George. As he pulled away from his bandmates, he invited Eric Clapton to duel with him.
5. “Hey Jude”, non-album single
Pretty good song. You may have heard it.
4. “Tomorrow Never Knows”, from Revolver
How many album covers from 1967 were images of bands turning off their minds, relaxing, and floating downstream? This song had more imitators than Elvis, but I’m not sure anyone has quite recreated the whole vibe, from the sitar freakout to vocals fed through a speaker cabinet to passages from The Tibetan Book of the Dead looped backwards. It’s a landmark recording no one else could have pulled off.
3. “I Saw Her Standing There”, from Please Please Me
A case can be made that The Beatles were two bands: the mop-topped cover band that set the world on fire in the early ’60s and the tireless innovators who expanded the language of music with each late-’60s release. Much like Paul’s “woooo” may never have happened if not for Little Richard, the second iteration of the Beatles may never have existed without the first. “I Saw Her Standing There”, track one on the group’s first studio album, is the pinnacle of the first wave and should be held in similar esteem to the great songs from the later period.
2. “I’ve Just Seen a Face”, from Help!
More than fifty years after the band’s demise, they still hold such power than no one in your life is “the Beatles guy” the way someone might be “the Steely Dan guy” or “the Pearl Jam girl”. To have a favorite Beatles song, generally, is to recognize the greatness of a song whose greatness practically everyone recognizes, but to hold it in even higher regard than the masses for one reason or another. My friend Dalton is a “Magical Mystery Tour” guy. My mom likes the mop-top days. Both are notable traits, but neither is an identity the way an obsession with Roy Orbison or Pat Benatar might be.
My favorite Beatles song is a deep cut from “Help!”. Right before the listener is mesmerized by “Yesterday”, two minutes of plucked guitar and giddy young love blow by so fast that you might not notice it. Preferring such a deep cut doesn’t make me interesting. To me, though, it makes The Beatles more fascinating. In addition to all the Let It Bes and Here Comes the Suns we know by heart, they wrote and recorded all-time great songs that you might not have noticed.
1. “A Day in the Life”, from Sgt. Pepper
“I’ve Just Seen a Face may be my favorite Beatles song, but that assessment may be colored by my desire to avoid the hegemony of what I perceived until this week as consensus around “A Day in the Life”. It’s the closer on one of the landmark albums in the rock canon. It maximizes the talents of two of the greatest songwriters in the history of the world, both of whom happened to grow up in Liverpool in the 1950s. McCartney fans get the factual account of the narrator’s morning ritual, a day like any other until he falls into a dream. Lennon fans get the dream: A suicide in a car. 4,000 holes to count in Blackburn, Lancashire. We all get the orchestra tying the day together and the acid trip through the band’s birth that closes the album. It’s not perfect. They’d already achieved perfection and kept marching forward. It’s a reimagining of what a song could be, a bold, new punctuation mark on a statement no one saw coming.
:format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-761153-1307687791.jpeg.jpg)
:format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-422713-1381516285-9185.jpeg.jpg)
:format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-620881-1391961143-5658.jpeg.jpg)
:format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-372268-1255068468.jpeg.jpg)
:format(jpeg):mode_rgb():quality(90)/discogs-images/R-9750848-1485786155-6468.jpeg.jpg)